Skip to main content

Criminal Defense

Juvenile Crimes

Demmery Law, PLLC is a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense law firm led by Attorney Tanner C. Demmery, a trial attorney and former Broward County prosecutor who defends juvenile delinquency cases under Chapter 985 of the Florida Statutes across Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe County.

Available 24/7
Former Prosecutor
Direct Attorney Access

What Happens When a Minor Is Arrested in Florida?

The case enters the juvenile justice system under Chapter 985 — a system separate from adult criminal court, with its own vocabulary, procedures, and dispositions, but with consequences that can follow a child for life. Instead of bail, detention decisions follow statutory criteria; instead of conviction and sentence, the system speaks of adjudication of delinquency and disposition. The early days matter enormously: children waive rights without realizing they have them, and statements made to school officials and police before a lawyer is involved often become the core of the State’s case. No child should be interviewed without counsel.

Can a Juvenile Be Charged as an Adult in Florida?

Yes — and the charging decision belongs largely to the State Attorney. Under Florida Statute § 985.557, the State Attorney may “direct file” a 16- or 17-year-old in adult court whenever, in the prosecutor’s judgment, the public interest requires adult sanctions; for 14- and 15-year-olds, direct file is available for a list of specified serious felonies. The forum decision often determines everything that follows: juvenile court offers diversion, probation, and rehabilitation-focused commitment, while adult court means adult sentencing exposure and an adult record. Early defense advocacy with the State Attorney’s Office — before the filing decision — is where this battle is won.

What Are the Possible Outcomes in Florida Juvenile Court?

They range from diversion programs that end with no adjudication at all, to probation with conditions like counseling and community service, to residential commitment in a Department of Juvenile Justice program. Juvenile court is built around rehabilitation, and judges have real flexibility — which means a prepared defense presentation about the child’s school record, family support, and treatment needs can genuinely change the outcome. Demmery Law approaches every juvenile case with both the immediate disposition and the long-term record in mind.

Do Juvenile Records Disappear Automatically in Florida?

Not as quickly or completely as parents assume. Under Florida Statute § 943.0515, a non-serious juvenile criminal history record is generally retained until two years after the child turns 19, and records of serious or habitual juvenile offenders are kept until five years after age 21 — and a later adult forcible-felony charge can merge the juvenile record into the adult one permanently. In the meantime, some juvenile records are accessible to schools, the military, and certain employers. Protecting the record is part of the defense, not an afterthought. A free consultation is available 24/7.

Florida Statutes & Penalties: Juvenile Crimes
Offense Florida Statute Level Potential Penalty
Juvenile delinquency jurisdiction and procedure Fla. Stat. ch. 985 Juvenile court Juvenile dispositions: diversion, probation, or residential commitment
Discretionary direct file — ages 16-17 Fla. Stat. § 985.557 Adult court (prosecutor's discretion) Adult sentencing exposure on the charged offense
Discretionary direct file — ages 14-15 (specified serious felonies) Fla. Stat. § 985.557 Adult court (prosecutor's discretion) Adult sentencing exposure on the charged offense
Retention of juvenile criminal history records Fla. Stat. § 943.0515 Records Expunged 2 years after age 19 (non-serious) or 5 years after age 21 (serious/habitual offenders), with exceptions

Source: Florida Statutes. Penalties shown are statutory maximums; actual outcomes depend on the facts of each case.

"Tanner is an exceptional criminal defense attorney who truly cares for his clients. He is transparent in his process and communicates all phases of the case."

— Chris G. Client · Google

Questions About Juvenile Crimes

Can police question my child without a parent present in Florida?
Generally yes — Florida law does not require a parent's presence for police to question a juvenile, though the child's age and the circumstances affect whether any statement was voluntary and admissible. Teach your child the essential rule: politely decline to answer questions and ask for a parent and a lawyer. Then call counsel before any interview.
Does a juvenile have the right to a jury trial in Florida?
No — juvenile delinquency cases are decided by a judge at an adjudicatory hearing, not by a jury. The State must still prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt, and the defense can challenge evidence, cross-examine witnesses, and present its own case. If a juvenile is direct filed to adult court, full adult jury trial rights apply.
Can colleges or the military see a juvenile record?
Sometimes, yes. Juvenile records are not as confidential as most families assume — certain dispositions are accessible to the military, some employers, and licensing agencies, and applications often ask questions that reach juvenile history. How the case resolves determines what remains visible, which is why the record strategy should be set at the start of the case.
What is a juvenile diversion program?
An alternative track that resolves the case without an adjudication of delinquency — typically requiring counseling, community service, restitution, or classes, with the case closed upon completion. Diversion eligibility depends on the charge and the child's history, and defense counsel can advocate for diversion with the State Attorney's Office before formal charges harden.
Can a minor be held in detention before their case is decided?
Yes — Florida uses secure detention for juveniles in defined circumstances, based on statutory criteria including the charge and the child's history, subject to prompt court review. Detention decisions can be contested, and an attorney's early involvement at the detention hearing can mean the child goes home while the case proceeds.
Can a juvenile record be expunged before the automatic date?
Florida law provides an early expunction path: a qualifying person may apply between ages 18 and 21 to expunge their juvenile criminal history if they have not been charged with a criminal offense in the preceding five years. Separate court-ordered sealing and expungement remedies may also apply depending on the disposition — an attorney can map which route fits.

Need Help With Your Case?

Talk to Tanner directly. Get an honest assessment and understand your options. No pressure. No obligation.

Request Your Free Case Review

(954) 224-0577 — Available 24/7

(954) 224-0577 Free Case Review