Skip to main content

Criminal Defense

Prescription Drug DUI

Demmery Law, PLLC is a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense law firm led by Attorney Tanner C. Demmery, a trial attorney and former Broward County prosecutor who defends prescription-medication DUI charges throughout Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe County.

Available 24/7
Former Prosecutor
Direct Attorney Access

Can You Get a DUI on Medication Your Doctor Prescribed?

Yes. Florida Statute § 316.193(1) makes it a DUI to drive with your normal faculties impaired by alcohol, a chemical substance listed in § 877.111, or any substance controlled under chapter 893 — and many common prescriptions are chapter 893 controlled substances. A valid prescription, taken exactly as directed, is not by itself a defense to impairment. People are routinely surprised by that, and the surprise leads to a costly mistake: telling the officer everything about their medications at the roadside, handing the State its impairment theory. A prescription DUI carries the same penalty structure as an alcohol DUI — fines, jail exposure, license revocation on conviction, and a permanent record.

Which Prescription Drugs Lead to DUI Charges in Florida?

The medications most often involved are scheduled controlled substances under § 893.03: opioid pain medications like oxycodone (Schedule II), benzodiazepines like alprazolam (Xanax) and diazepam (Valium) (Schedule IV), and sleep aids like zolpidem (Ambien) (Schedule IV). Because these substances do not appear on a breath test, the State’s case is built from blood toxicology, a drug recognition evaluation, and the arresting officer’s observations rather than a single incriminating number.

How Does the State Prove Impairment Without a Breath Number?

Usually through a Drug Recognition Expert evaluation, blood test results, and the officer’s narrative — and each is challengeable. The DRE protocol is a 12-step police procedure, not a scientific instrument, and it has well-documented limitations: defense work reviews whether the protocol was followed, whether the officer’s certification is current, and whether the conclusions actually match the toxicology. Blood draws are examined for chain-of-custody and laboratory-methodology problems, and therapeutic drug levels consistent with prescribed use undercut the impairment theory. As a former Broward County prosecutor, Tanner knows how the State Attorney’s Office evaluates the strength of a drug-DUI case before trial — and what concessions follow when the defense pushes back hard on the science.

What Happens to Your License and Career After a Prescription DUI?

A conviction triggers the same consequences as an alcohol DUI: license revocation, possible ignition interlock, fines, probation, and a permanent criminal record. For clients in healthcare, transportation, law, education, or any licensed profession, the collateral consequences can outweigh the criminal sentence itself. Demmery Law builds defenses that protect not just the case but the career that depends on it — weighing outcomes like a withhold of adjudication against their licensing-board impact. The consultation is free, the phone is answered 24/7, and you work directly with the attorney on a flat fee.

Florida Statutes & Penalties: Prescription Drug DUI
Offense Florida Statute Level Potential Penalty
DUI — impairment by controlled substance (first conviction) Fla. Stat. § 316.193(1)(a), (2)(a) Misdemeanor Up to 6 months jail, $500–$1,000 fine
DUI — second conviction Fla. Stat. § 316.193(2)(a) Misdemeanor Up to 9 months jail, $1,000–$2,000 fine, interlock at least 1 year
DUI causing property damage or non-serious injury Fla. Stat. § 316.193(3)(c)1. First-degree misdemeanor Up to 1 year jail
Possession of a controlled substance without a valid prescription Fla. Stat. § 893.13(6)(a) Third-degree felony Up to 5 years prison

Source: Florida Statutes. Penalties shown are statutory maximums; actual outcomes depend on the facts of each case.

"Tanner is an exceptional criminal defense attorney who truly cares for his clients. He is transparent in his process and communicates all phases of the case."

— Chris G. Client · Google

Questions About Prescription Drug DUI

Can I be arrested for DUI if I took my medication exactly as prescribed?
Yes. Florida's DUI statute reaches any chapter 893 controlled substance that impairs your normal faculties — including medication taken in the prescribed dose. The 'do not operate heavy machinery' warning on the label is exactly what the State will point to. A valid prescription shapes the defense strategy, but it is not automatic immunity from the charge.
Should I tell the officer about my medications during a traffic stop?
No — you have the right to remain silent, and listing your medications at the roadside hands the State its impairment theory before any test exists. Provide your license, registration, and insurance, and politely decline to discuss what you have taken. Statements about medication are among the most damaging evidence in prescription DUI cases.
Can a Drug Recognition Expert's findings be challenged in court?
Yes. The DRE protocol is a 12-step law enforcement procedure, not a scientific instrument, and it has well-documented limitations. Defense counsel challenges whether the protocol was followed, whether the officer's training and certification are current, and whether the conclusions actually fit the blood toxicology. DRE evidence is strong when properly administered and weak when it is not.
What if my blood test only shows a normal therapeutic level?
A therapeutic level consistent with prescribed use is a meaningful defense fact. Florida has no per se threshold for prescription drugs, so the State must prove actual impairment — and a normal medication level undercuts the theory that the drug, rather than fatigue or a medical condition, explains the officer's observations. These cases often turn on exactly this fight.
Can I be charged with DUI for a medication that is not a controlled substance?
Florida's DUI statute applies to impairment by alcohol, chemical substances listed in § 877.111, or substances controlled under chapter 893. Whether a particular medication falls within those categories is a threshold legal question your attorney examines first — most prescription DUI prosecutions involve scheduled drugs like opioids, benzodiazepines, or sleep aids, which are controlled under § 893.03.
Will a prescription DUI affect my professional license?
Often yes. Healthcare providers, attorneys, teachers, commercial drivers, and other licensed professionals are typically required to report arrests or convictions to their boards. Defense strategy needs to weigh the criminal outcome against the licensing impact — sometimes a withhold of adjudication is the right resolution, sometimes it is not. That calculation should happen at the start of the case, not the end.

Need Help With Your Case?

Talk to Tanner directly. Get an honest assessment and understand your options. No pressure. No obligation.

Request Your Free Case Review

(954) 224-0577 — Available 24/7

(954) 224-0577 Free Case Review