Skip to main content

Criminal Defense

Restraining Order Defense

Demmery Law, PLLC is a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense law firm led by Attorney Tanner C. Demmery, a trial attorney and former Broward County prosecutor who defends respondents in injunction-for-protection proceedings — and the criminal exposure that often runs alongside them — across Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe County.

Available 24/7
Former Prosecutor
Direct Attorney Access

What Happens When You Are Served With an Injunction in Florida?

You are typically already subject to a temporary order entered without your side being heard. Florida courts can issue a temporary injunction ex parte — on the petition alone — for a fixed period of up to 15 days, with a full hearing set before the temporary order expires. That hearing is your one real opportunity: a final injunction can bar contact with the petitioner, restrict where you go, address temporary custody and use of shared property, and strip firearm possession under federal law while it remains in effect. Treating the paperwork casually is the most expensive mistake respondents make.

What Does the Petitioner Have to Prove at the Final Hearing?

The petitioner must prove the statutory grounds for the specific injunction sought — domestic violence under Florida Statute § 741.30, repeat, dating, or sexual violence under § 784.046, or stalking under § 784.0485 — by a preponderance of the evidence. The respondent has the right to cross-examine the petitioner, present witnesses, introduce documents, and testify. Many respondents go in unrepresented and lose because they did not understand the burden of proof or how to challenge the allegations. Demmery Law prepares injunction hearings the way it prepares criminal trials: exhibit lists, cross-examination outlines, the petitioner’s prior inconsistent statements, and witnesses for the respondent.

Is Violating a Restraining Order a Crime in Florida?

Yes — a willful violation of a domestic violence injunction is a first-degree misdemeanor under § 741.31, and violating a repeat, dating, or sexual violence injunction is a first-degree misdemeanor under § 784.047, each punishable by up to a year in jail. A person with two or more prior violation convictions who violates an injunction against the same victim commits a third-degree felony. Violation allegations are easy to make and aggressively prosecuted, which is why respondents must follow the order to the letter even when the petitioner initiates contact.

What Are the Long-Term Consequences If an Injunction Is Granted?

They reach far beyond the no-contact terms. A final injunction can be entered for a fixed term or indefinitely depending on the type and circumstances; federal law generally bars firearm possession for its duration; Florida courts may weigh an injunction in family-law custody proceedings; and employers, licensing boards, and immigration authorities ask about restraining orders and treat them with skepticism. Defending the petition vigorously at the final hearing is the only realistic chance to keep those consequences from attaching — and Demmery Law offers a free consultation, available 24/7, to respondents who have just been served.

Florida Statutes & Penalties: Restraining Order Defense
Offense Florida Statute Level Potential Penalty
Violation of a domestic violence injunction Fla. Stat. § 741.31(4) Misdemeanor — first degree Up to 1 year county jail, up to $1,000 fine
Violation of a repeat, dating, or sexual violence injunction Fla. Stat. § 784.047 Misdemeanor — first degree Up to 1 year county jail, up to $1,000 fine
Injunction violation with two or more prior violation convictions (same victim) Fla. Stat. §§ 741.31, 784.047 Felony — third degree Up to 5 years prison, up to $5,000 fine

Source: Florida Statutes. Penalties shown are statutory maximums; actual outcomes depend on the facts of each case.

"Tanner is an exceptional criminal defense attorney who truly cares for his clients. He is transparent in his process and communicates all phases of the case."

— Chris G. Client · Google

Questions About Restraining Order Defense

Can I contact the petitioner to work things out after being served with an injunction?
No — absolutely not. Any contact while a temporary injunction is in effect can be charged as a criminal violation and will be used against you at the final hearing. All communication should go through your attorney. Even an apology text can become the State's best evidence.
Should I go to my injunction hearing without a lawyer?
You can, but it is a serious gamble. The final hearing is a real evidentiary proceeding with testimony, cross-examination, and exhibits, and respondents who appear unprepared routinely lose hearings they could have won. The consequences — firearms, custody, employment, a permanent court record — last far longer than the hearing itself.
Do I have to give up my guns if an injunction is entered against me?
Generally yes. Federal law bars firearm possession while a qualifying final injunction is in effect, and courts address surrender of firearms as part of the order. This consequence attaches even though the injunction is a civil matter — one of several reasons to contest the petition rather than accept it by default.
Can a final injunction be dissolved or modified later in Florida?
Yes — either party can move to modify or dissolve an injunction, and respondents can seek dissolution when circumstances have changed. Courts do not grant these motions lightly, however, and winning the final hearing in the first place is far easier than undoing an injunction afterward.
Will a restraining order show up on a background check?
Injunction proceedings are civil court records, and final injunctions are accessible in court records that employers, licensing boards, and others can find. An injunction is not a criminal conviction, but in practice it raises the same red flags — which is why contesting an unjustified petition matters.
What happens if the petitioner contacts me first while the injunction is active?
You are still bound by the order — it restricts you, not the petitioner, and responding to their contact can still be charged as a violation. Document the contact, do not respond, and tell your attorney; a petitioner who repeatedly initiates contact may give your lawyer grounds to seek modification or dissolution.

Need Help With Your Case?

Talk to Tanner directly. Get an honest assessment and understand your options. No pressure. No obligation.

Request Your Free Case Review

(954) 224-0577 — Available 24/7

(954) 224-0577 Free Case Review